Despite its gripping storytelling, well-written and developed characters, and intense action sequences, Banana Fish remains one of the most underrated anime in recent years. The anime was released in 2018 and was adapted from Akimi Yoshida’s 1995 classic manga. It modernized the setting of the series while keeping the raw emotions and intense theme very much intact. However, Banana Fish hasn’t received the widespread recognition as well as the mainstream status it deserves. So, what makes this anime so special, and why does it still remain underrated? Let’s deep dive into it.

1. A Gripping and Mature Storyline

Unlike many mainstream anime that usually focus on fantasy and low-key themes, Banana Fish tackles real-world issues that are not usually discussed at a wider level. Such realism is very rare in anime these days. The story follows Ash Lynx, a charismatic, intelligent, but deeply traumatized gang leader in New York City, who uncovers a conspiracy surrounding a mysterious drug on the streets called “Banana Fish.” Along the way, he meets Eiji Okumura, a kind-hearted Japanese photographer who becomes his closest companion. Their journey is filled with intense action, crime, emotional moments, and shocking twists, making it one of the most thrilling and thought-provoking narratives in anime.

Personally, what I believe makes this story stand out is that it has the perfect balance of action, drama, deep and important connections mixed with the best portrayal of harsh realities of survival in this cruel world.

2. Complex and Well-Written Characters

One of the strongest strengths of “Banana Fish” is its character depth. Each and every one of the characters in this series is very well written, highlighting their own internal struggles and relationships that feel genuine and impactful.

Ash Lynx is not your typical anime protagonist—he’s gifted, ruthless when necessary, but also deeply scarred by his past. Raised in a hole full of crime and abuse, his fighting abilities along with his intelligence make him a perfect leader, but his trauma and vulnerability make him incredibly human. 

Eiji Okumura, gentle and optimistic photographer. His kindness and warmth help Ash find someone he can trust in a place where he was all alone. He serves as Ash’s emotional anchor and his closest, most trustworthy ally, giving him hope in his dark reality. Their bond is one of the most beautifully written relationships in anime history.

Dino Golzine, the main antagonist, is a powerful and chilling villain whose manipulation and control over Ash make him truly terrifying. His obsession over him makes him very terrifying but also tragic, as he represents the abuse of power.

Each character is crafted with depth, making the viewer emotionally invested in their fate.

3. A Unique Setting and Realistic Depiction of Crime

Unlike the typical anime settings, Banana Fish is different. It takes place in a realistic, crime-filled New York City. The series doesn’t shy away from portraying the brutal reality of gang violence, human trafficking, and corruption in the city. It does not romanticize crime, but instead it gives us a raw and transparent yet disturbing portrayal of power struggles. This is what sets ‘Banana Fish’ apart from all the mainstream anime, giving us a thrilling drama instead of the usual action series.

4. Emotional Depth and Heart-Breaking Moments

What makes Banana Fish truly unforgettable is its emotional impact. The show explores trauma, loss, love, and survival, making viewers deeply connect with its characters along with motivating them that even they, despite the circumstances, can get through whatever life throws at them. Ash and Eiji’s relationship is the heart of the story, and their bond is both heart-warming and tragic. Whether you view it as a romantic relationship or a tragic love story, it is one of the most beautifully written bonds in the anime universe.

The emotional weight of ‘Banana Fish’ is something that sticks with the viewers long after they finish watching.

5. The Reason Why It’s Underrated

 Despite having very strong viewers and a devoted fanbase, it still hasn’t gained the same mainstream success as any other anime. Here’s why:

• Genre Bias: Many viewers gravitate towards the more common and heavy action genre-based anime (Naruto, My Hero Academia, Demon Slayer). Banana Fish is a crime drama with a very heavy emotional and psychological focus, which audiences these days usually overlook. • Mature Themes: The dark and heavy subject matter may not be that appealing to the usual anime watchers.

• Initial Art Style Perception: Some viewers may be put off by its modern character designs as compared to the manga’s older style. However, the animations and the cinematography are perfectly done.

• Mature Themes: Banana Fish deals with very dark and sensitive topics of our world, which may not be appealing to everyone. Most anime fans prefer lighter content that can be used as an escape.

Closing Thoughts

Banana Fish is a must-watch that deserves more recognition, and it’s a hidden gem that more people need to experience in this lifetime.

Eyra.